Showing posts sorted by relevance for query DOMA. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query DOMA. Sort by date Show all posts

Friday, May 7, 2010

The DOMA arguments

Yesterday, arguments were heard in a targeted challenge to DOMA, in Gill v. Office of Personnel Management. From GLAD's press release:
Bonauto presented a three-pronged legal argument: By singling out only the marriages of same-sex couples, DOMA violates the equal protection clause of the United States Constitution; DOMA represents an unprecedented intrusion of the federal government into marriage law, which for 230 years has been legislated by states; and by denying federal protections to families, DOMA burdens the marriages of same-sex couples and their right to maintain family integrity.
The DoJ attorney defending DOMA agrees that the president opposes it, but argued that it is constitutional and must be defended. Which he did, aggressively. But he had to deal with the fact that prior to DOMA, the federal government accepted the definition of marriage from each individual state. For example, some states allow marriage between cousins; others do not. But if the marriage is legal in the state in which it was performed, traditionally the federal government has accepted that state's determination.

From the Advocate:
[Judge Tauro] asked Bonauto whether the government had legitimate arguments in saying DOMA was necessary to preserve a “status quo” concerning the federal understanding of marriage or to adapt federal law to the changing understanding of marriage incrementally.

“No, your honor,” said Bonauto: DOMA did not preserve a status quo, it upended one. Bonauto pointed out that prior to DOMA the federal government accepted each state’s definition of marriage.

It was on this point that Judge Tauro pressed the government most vigorously, asking Department of Justice attorney Scott Simpson, “When did it become a federal matter — dealing with marriage?”

Simpson, who has been DOJ’s point man for defending DOMA, tried to step around the question, but Tauro redirected his question more bluntly. “Specifically, point to an incident,” said Tauro, when marriage has been a federal matter prior to DOMA. Simpson had to concede: “it’s true” that, up until DOMA, the federal government has “simply followed the states’ definition of marriage.”
More arguments will follow.

Good sites for updates:
Prop8trialtracker
Hunter of Justice
LGBT POV
And of course, the Advocate and GLAD.

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Anti-DOMA suits update

You may remember a great kerfuffle a while back, over the release of a DoJ brief about DOMA. That case, Smelt, was not viewed as a particularly good one to challenge DOMA but the unnecessary harshness of the brief caused a firestorm in the blogs for days (go here for a list of all my posts on this topic).

On Monday, the DoJ released a reply brief to Smelt. Pam' s House Blend has the backstory on this AP report:
The Obama administration filed court papers Monday claiming a federal marriage law discriminates against gays, even as government lawyers continued to defend it......

In court papers, the administration said it supports repeal of the law. Yet the same filing says the Justice Department will defend the statute in this case because a reasonable argument can be made that the law is constitutional.....

"The United States does not believe that DOMA is rationally related to any legitimate government interests in procreation and child-rearing and is therefore not relying upon any such interests to defend DOMA's constitutionality," lawyers argued in the filing.
Okay, so they are still defending it....but they now have put in writing that they believe DOMA is wrong.

I can't help believe that this is an improvement. I expect the usual suspects will be up in arms about any defense, but it's typical of the Obama approach of softly softly. The law needs to be defended on principle, even if they believe it should be repealed through appropriate channels.

LawDork comments,
From the brief itself to Obama’s statement and in light of the other changes being advanced by the Administration, I continue to believe that the original DOJ Smelt filing was made without the full appreciation (or knowledge) by higher-ups. I do think that the uproar following its filing has changed the approach of the Administration, and, for that, the debate was worthwhile. This filing and statement show an awareness of and sensitivity to that impact, while maintaining a clear principle to defend a law that repeatedly has been found to be constitutional.
Meanwhile, there's another case against DOMA making its way through the courts, Gill which is generally viewed as a stronger one. It challenges the distinctly different treatment of married couples in MA in dealing with federal agencies. Because these couples are being actively discriminated against now (as legally married) this is viewed as a very strong argument against DOMA, or at least against the part of it that prevents Federal Recognition of legal same sex marriage.

As highlighted by LawDork, the plaintiffs have amended their complaint with some more powerful language, particularly around the tax inequities. Here are some choice quotes from the amended brief.
Although each of the plaintiffs is similarly situated to all other married or widowed persons in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, DOMA, 1 U.S.C. § 7, requires the plaintiffs to deny the existence of their families and the nature of their familial relationships. DOMA, 1 U.S.C. § 7, thereby causes confusion and complexity in a culture where people are expected to have one familial and marital status, whether dealing with private, state or federal entities.
The federal government’s refusal to recognize the plaintiffs’ marriages does not nurture, improve, stabilize or enhance the marriages of other married couples. Nor would the federal government’s recognition of plaintiffs’ marriages degrade, destabilize or have any other deleterious effect on the marriages of other married couples.
Congress has yet to identify a reason why gay and lesbian individuals who have met their obligations as taxpaying citizens and who are married to someone of the same sex must be denied protections available to persons who are married to someone of a different sex. Singling out same-sex couples who are married among all married persons is simply an expression of the intent to discriminate against gay people.

I wonder whether the DoJ "tipped its hand" in the Smelt case enough to allow more targeted arguments here. And what difference the new filing will make.

So to sum up: THREE cases underway in Federal Court. TWO anti-DOMA cases (Smelt, and Gill) plus ONE anti-Prop8 case also in federal court (Perry v. Schwarzenegger). The DOMA cases are defended by the DoJ as they apply to existing federal law. The Prop8 case is against the state of California but under Federal Constitutional grounds (the previous challenge was to the State Supreme Court under California constitution issues). It is defended by the pro-H8 folks, since the State of California agrees that Prop8 offends the equal protection clause of the US Constitution.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Breaking: DOJ won't defend sec. 3 of DOMA

I have been following several federal cases that challenge section 3 of DOMA, which forbids the Federal Government from recognizing legal same sex marriages. (The other section says that STATES don't have to recognize them).

Numerous challenges have been brought that point out that the Federal Government is treating legally married citizens differently according to their gender. The furthest along is in Massachusetts, where a Federal Judge found for the married couples, and appeals were being files to take it to the Circuit court of appeal, and from there possibly to the Supreme Court. There are other cases pending too.

Now, the Dept of Justice announces they will not defend section 3 in two cases in the 2nd District court. (Despite claims otherwise, they are not required to defend if they don't want to). Other cases, confusingly, will continue to move forward; it appears this is specific to the 2nd district because there isn't already precedent there.
In the two years since this Administration took office, the Department of Justice has defended Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act on several occasions in federal court. Each of those cases evaluating Section 3 was considered in jurisdictions in which binding circuit court precedents hold that laws singling out people based on sexual orientation, as DOMA does, are constitutional if there is a rational basis for their enactment. While the President opposes DOMA and believes it should be repealed, the Department has defended it in court because we were able to advance reasonable arguments under that rational basis standard.

Section 3 of DOMA has now been challenged in the Second Circuit, however, which has no established or binding standard for how laws concerning sexual orientation should be treated. In these cases, the Administration faces for the first time the question of whether laws regarding sexual orientation are subject to the more permissive standard of review or whether a more rigorous standard, under which laws targeting minority groups with a history of discrimination are viewed with suspicion by the courts, should apply.

After careful consideration, including a review of my recommendation, the President has concluded that given a number of factors, including a documented history of discrimination, classifications based on sexual orientation should be subject to a more heightened standard of scrutiny. The President has also concluded that Section 3 of DOMA, as applied to legally married same-sex couples, fails to meet that standard and is therefore unconstitutional. Given that conclusion, the President has instructed the Department not to defend the statute in such cases. I fully concur with the President’s determination.

Consequently, the Department will not defend the constitutionality of Section 3 of DOMA as applied to same-sex married couples in the two cases filed in the Second Circuit. We will, however, remain parties to the cases and continue to represent the interests of the United States throughout the litigation. I have informed Members of Congress of this decision, so Members who wish to defend the statute may pursue that option. The Department will also work closely with the courts to ensure that Congress has a full and fair opportunity to participate in pending litigation.

Furthermore, pursuant to the President ’ s instructions, and upon further notification to Congress, I will instruct Department attorneys to advise courts in other pending DOMA litigation of the President's and my conclusions that a heightened standard should apply, that Section 3 is unconstitutional under that standard and that the Department will cease defense of Section 3.

The Department has a longstanding practice of defending the constitutionality of duly-enacted statutes if reasonable arguments can be made in their defense. At the same time, the Department in the past has declined to defend statutes despite the availability of professionally responsible arguments, in part because – as here – the Department does not consider every such argument to be a “reasonable” one. Moreover, the Department has declined to defend a statute in cases, like this one, where the President has concluded that the statute is unconstitutional.

Much of the legal landscape has changed in the 15 years since Congress passed DOMA. The Supreme Court has ruled that laws criminalizing homosexual conduct are unconstitutional. Congress has repealed the military’s Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell policy. Several lower courts have ruled DOMA itself to be unconstitutional. Section 3 of DOMA will continue to remain in effect unless Congress repeals it or there is a final judicial finding that strikes it down, and the President has informed me that the Executive Branch will continue to enforce the law. But while both the wisdom and the legality of Section 3 of DOMA will continue to be the subject of both extensive litigation and public debate, this Administration will no longer assert its constitutionality in court.
Put on your helmets as wingnut heads are going to explode.

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Obama DoJ and the DOMA appeal

The president may coyly suggest that his feelings about marriage equality are "evolving", but his DoJ is still claiming rational government interest in DOMA, the so called defense of marriage act. They are appealing the Massachusetts federal district court that found it unconstitutional to deny legally married Massachusetts couples the federal benefits of marriage.

As Politico notes:
"There are some improvements in tone in the brief, but the bottom line is the government continues to oppose full equality for its gay citizens," said Equality Matters chief Richard Socarides in an e-mail. "And that is unacceptable."


From Chris Geidner at Poliglot:
Despite that "ongoing dialogue," the government asserts three reasons to justify DOMA's continued validity:

1. Congress Could Have Rationally Concluded That DOMA Promotes A Legitimate Interest in Preserving a National Status Quo at the Federal Level While States Engage in a Period of Evaluation of and Experience with Opening Marriage to Same-Sex Couples.

2. Congress Could Reasonably Conclude That DOMA Serves a Legitimate Federal Interest in Uniform Application of Federal Law Within and Across States During a Period When Important State Laws Differ.

3. Congress Could Reasonably Have Believed That by Maintaining the Status Quo, DOMA Serves the General Federal Interest of Respecting Policy Development among the States While Preserving the Authority of Each Sovereign to Choose its Own Course.

Although each is slightly different, these three "rationales" do read like different shades of the same argument, which is more or less that DOMA made sense -- or, is rational -- because the states hadn't reached a uniform decision.


BUT as I've noted before, the DoJ basically has to appeal this if it is to have any bearing outside of Massachusetts. And there are some interesting statements in the brief (see the original for the references)

This one is interesting because it undercuts the primary argument being used by the defenders of Prop8: gays can't procreate. The government is conceding that this argument is not rational.
[T]he government does not contend that DOMA serves a governmental interest in “responsible procreation and child- rearing.” As the government explained in district court, since the enactment of DOMA, many leading medical, psychological, and social welfare organizations have concluded, based on numerous studies, that children raised by gay and lesbian parents are as likely to be well-adjusted as children raised by heterosexual parents. The district court nonetheless addressed that rationale, and certain other rationales the government did not advance, and rejected them as irrational. The government does not challenge those specific aspects of the district court ruling on appeal.
p.50


This one is an admission that times are changing, and the way things are is harmful to gays and lesbians.
When DOMA was enacted, the institution of marriage had long been understood as a formal relationship between a man and a woman, and state and federal law had been built on that understanding. But our society is evolving, and as is well-established, the “science of government . . . is the science of experiment.” Over the years, the prevailing concept of marriage has been challenged as unfair to a significant element of the population. Recently there has been a growing recognition that the prevailing regime is harmful to gay and lesbian members of our society.
p51

This one points out the complications without DOMA.
Without DOMA, federal benefits would vary for same-sex couples from state to state. Couples in a state that allowed same-sex couples to marry would receive certain federal benefits, while couples in a state that did not authorize such marriages would not. Further, several states have created a civil union or domestic partnership regime that provides, under state law, virtually all of the same rights and benefits as marriage. Under current federal law those partnerships – whether same-sex or opposite-sex – do not qualify as marriages. Given the differing treatment in the states of committed relationships between same-sex couples, Congress could have rationally concluded that a uniform federal definition was warranted. And while it may be preferable as a policy matter for Congress to have provided the same benefits to all married couples, the uniform path that Congress chose was permissible….
THe argument being that it's better to just lump the gays into disadvantage than try to figure out the inconsistencies from state to state.

Of course, the lunacy of this is notable in California, where the brief argues that it wouldn't be fair to have married gay couples have benefits that are no longer available to other gay couples.
….a uniform federal definition eliminates not only variations among the states, but variation in federal benefits for same-sex couples within the same state. As explained above, in California, same-sex couples married between June 2008 and November 2008 remain in recognized marriages in that state, but no more such marriages may be performed. Thus same-sex couples formally united during that period would benefit from federal laws regarding marriages, but other same-sex couples seeking to marry in the state would not. p.67
Stay tuned, we'll keep you posted.

Monday, June 20, 2011

DOMA defense update

Chris Geidner fills us in on the recent motion filed in the first DOMA case to be defended by the Congressional Republican caucus.

Background: the Obama Administration has decided that the Dept of Justice cannot defend DOMA, the defense of marriage act that renders my legal marriage federally invisible, because they believe it is unconstitutional. However, the law remains on the books and is still in force. Congressional Republicans have decided to spend your dollars on a private attorney to defend the indefensibly hate-filled DOMA. (Meanwhile, a repeal bill entitled the Respect for Marriage Act is moving slowly through Congress).

This particular DOMA case is of a legally married California woman, Karen Golinski, who has sought health insurance benefits for her wife from her employer, ironically the 9th Circuit Federal Court. The Court has actually supported Golinski but the Administration's Office of Personnel Management has refused to comply based on DOMA.

Now the case is a lawsuit, and Paul Clement, the attorney hired by the Republicans, will vigorously defend DOMA and attack same sex couples.

Treating us as second class, according to Clement, is justifiable because (1) gay marriage is new, (2) the whole procreation thing (he goes into Gallagher territory) and (3)

Finally, it bears emphasizing that DOMA’s effect is limited. DOMA only defines marriage for purposes of benefits—and burdens—, created by other federal laws. … Congress "did not penalize" same sex couples; it "decided not to offer them a special inducement."
I also find it interesting that he throws in a line about "political power" of gay rights supporters. You may recall that in the Prop8 trial, the relative powerlessness of LGBT people was contested.

Here's the ultimate test of power: do we have enough power to protect ourselves politically without the courts? do we have enough power to ensure our EQUAL TREATMENT under the law? DOMA and Prop8 prove that we so not.

There is no justification for DOMA and the deliberate harming of legally married same sex couples. None, except religiously-inspired bigotry, ignorance, hate and fear.

All of which will no doubt be given a glossy paint job by Attorney Paul Clement.

Friday, September 18, 2009

BREAKING: DoJ argues to dismiss 2nd anti-DOMA case

A while ago, I updated you on the ongoingfederal court cases relevant to marriage equality: Gill and Smelt, on DOMA, and Perry, on Prop8. Smelt was subsequently dismissed, on a technicality.

Gill originates in Massachusetts and argues that it is unconsitutitonal to treat legally married Massachusetts citizens differently under federal law simply because they are gay. According to the NY TImes, Obama's DoJ has just filed a brief asking for the dismissal of Gill. This is another brief that says, "we don't like DOMA, but it's the law and we think it's constitutional".

Lawdork comments,
On the substance of its defense of DOMA, DOJ plays a little too cute, parsing the marriage prohibitions as a state matter and DOMA as just a matter of federal benefits. Id. at 14 (”DOMA deprives same-sex couples of certain federal benefits that are tied to marital status. There is no fundamental right, however, to marriage-based federal benefits.”)......

DOJ then asserts that First Circuit precedent prohibits the District Court from considering this case under the strict scrutiny review urged, in part, by GLAD in its Complaint. Strict scrutiny review is the most search review, in which the government needs to show a “compelling interest” for the law and show that the law is “narrowly tailored” to that interest. DOJ argues:

The First Circuit has concluded, however, that sexual orientation does not constitute a suspect classification under the Fifth Amendment, and that holding is binding on this Court. . . . .


Then, in urging that DOMA be upheld under rational basis — the most deferential — review, DOJ goes into a new and interesting argument, essentially that DOMA prevents federal government benefits from being a mismatch differing by state based on the whims of those states. I’ve not seen an argument like this before:

As the state legislative and constitutional activity in the years since DOMA was enacted demonstrates, same-sex marriage is a contentious social issue. Given the evolving nature of this issue, Congress was constitutionally entitled to maintain the status quo pending further evolution in the states. Otherwise, “marriage” and “spouse” for the purposes of federal law would depend on the outcome of this debate in each State, with the meanings of those terms under federal law potentially changing with any change in the status of the debate in a given State. Federal rights would vary dramatically from State to State. Congress could reasonably have concluded that there is a legitimate government interest in maintaining the status quo and preserving nationwide consistency in the distribution of marriage-based federal benefits.
GLAD's press release in response:
Mary L. Bonauto, GLAD’s Civil Rights Project Director and co-lead counsel in Gill, said “Nothing in the government’s brief addresses the fact that DOMA is the sole exception in a long history of the federal government deferring to the states’ determination that people are married. Obviously we disagree with any argument that DOMA is constitutional. Married same-sex couples are being treated differently from other married couples. To us, that’s a clear-cut violation of the promise of equal protection.”

Gary Buseck, GLAD’s Legal Director said, “We’re seeking justice for the widows and widowers who are denied death benefits, for people who can’t get on their spouse’s health plan, for parents who can’t file taxes jointly and pay thousands extra each year that they could put away for their children’s education or family emergencies.”

I am so tired of my rights as a US citizen been argued in this way.

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Four possible outcomes from the Supreme Court

On Friday, the court will conference on whether to hear any of the cases before it (Prop8, several DOMA cases, and a case from AZ on partner benefits). From Chris Geidner, a consideration of the possible outcomes. I'm hoping for version 4.

• The court takes multiple DOMA cases and the Proposition 8 case. This outcome would be the “all in” option, and it would make clear that at least four justices want the court to resolve the legal questions surrounding these issues, from what level of scrutiny that laws classifying people based on sexual orientation should be given (see more about this here) to whether gay couples have a constitutional right to marry..... 
• The court takes one DOMA case, while holding the other DOMA cases pending that decision, and takes the Proposition 8 case as well. This is not very different from the first possibility, although the choice of one DOMA case over another could be seen as narrowing the type of argument about the law that the court would like to hear. ... 
• The court takes a DOMA case (or multiple DOMA cases) and holds the rest of the cases, including Proposition 8, pending the outcome of the DOMA case. This prospect, advanced as a possibility by Georgetown law professor Nan Hunter, could be taken by a cautious court, wanting first to resolve some general questions — including the level of scrutiny to be applied to sexual orientation classifications — before acting on the other, more direct, question about whether same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry that is raised in the Proposition 8 challenge. .... 
• The court takes a DOMA case (or multiple DOMA cases), but denies certiorari in the Proposition 8 case. This option, once considered by advocates to be the most likely possibility, would lead to same-sex couples being able to marry in California within days. The Ninth Circuit’s ruling in the case did not broadly resolve the marriage question, instead holding that Proposition 8 was unconstitutional because it took back rights formerly held by Californians. As there are other cases in the legal pipeline about same-sex couples marriage rights that could make their way to the Supreme Court, the court could decide to let the narrow Ninth Circuit decision stand.

Friday, June 12, 2009

Obama's DoJ defends DOMA

We've been talking for sometime about whether Obama will do anything about DOMA.

Well, his DOJ will actively SUPPORT it. The DoJ has filed a brief defending DOMA in California, with every right-wing anti-gay talking point you would expect from a Bush Administration.

The SF Chronicle reports
This case does not call upon the Court to pass judgment ... on the legal or moral right of same-sex couples, such as plaintiffs here, to be married," the motion states. "Plaintiffs are married, and their challenge to the federal Defense of Marriage Act ("DOMA") poses a different set of questions.

"It's a different case from a recent federal lawsuit by two unmarried gay couples in California who claim a civil right to marry under the U.S. Constitution.

The government said Smelt and Hammer seek a ruling on "whether by virtue of their marital status they are constitutionally entitled to acknowledgment of their union by states that do not recognize same-sex marriage, and whether they are similarly entitled to certain federal benefits.

"Under the law binding on this Court, the answer to these questions must be no," the motion states.

Americablog quotes the brief, which cites incest as a justification for denying marriage recognition. A big part of it claims DOMA is good for the federal budget, because if you deprive people of rights, it's cheaper. Now remember, this is OBAMA'S Department of Justice.
Likewise, Section 3 of DOMA merely clarifies that federal policy is to make certain benefits available only to those persons united in heterosexual marriage, as opposed to any other possible relationship defined by law, family, or affection. As a result, gay and lesbian individuals who unite in matrimony are denied no federal benefits to which they were entitled prior to their marriage; they remain eligible for every benefit they enjoyed beforehand. DOMA simply provides, in effect, that as a result of their same-sex marriage they will not become eligible for the set of benefits that Congress has reserved exclusively to those who are related by the bonds of heterosexual marriage. In short, then, the failure in this manner to recognize a certain subset of marriages that are recognized by a certain subset of States cannot be taken as an infringement on plaintiffs' rights, even if same-sex marriage were accepted as a fundamental right under the Constitution.

The whole brief is here. (This is not the high-profile case recently filed by Boies and Olson. This is an earlier case.)

I posted this originally at Daily Kos, where many commenters pointed out that the DoJ has to defend a legal statute. After all, one of the complaints about the Bush administration was their politicization of the DoJ, which is supposed to function independently. DOMA is legal, like it or not, until the spineless Congresscritters repeal it. But the language in the brief is incendiary. My marriage is not to be recognized for the same reason incestuous marriages are not recognized? It's vastly insulting. And there is a strong defense of DOMA for purely BUDGETARY reasons.

Which leads me back to a diary I wrote a few days ago. Is Obama really moving slowly on gay rights, or is he being very subtle? Is comparing our marriages to incest and supporting DOMA by citing the budget meant to be so ridiculous an argument that any sane person would dismiss it? I wish I knew.

Friday, July 9, 2010

Update on DOMA cases

There were actually two cases, which I had conflated in some of my earlier posts.

Gill vs. Office of Personnel Management:
argued by GLAD, this case brings suit on behalf of several legally married Massachusetts couples who were treated unequally by the Federal Government. Nancy Gill works for the postal service but is unable to cover her wife on the USPS plan or obtain other work benefits that are available to heterosexual married couples, and argued this violated equal protection principles since she is legally married.

Commonwealth vs. Department of Health and Human Services, argued by the Massachusetts State Attorney General, was based on the fact that the federal government told the state that it could not extend benefits (like the state Health insurance program) to same-sex spouses, on penalty of losing federal aid dollars. This case argued that DOMA infringed improperly on the state's sovereign right to determine who is married.

Both of these challenged just section 3 of DOMA, which states that the federal government will not recognize legal state marriages between same sex couples. (Section 2 excuses states from recognizing each other's marriages. That was not addressed.) The Judge found that Section 3 was invalid under two constitutional tests: equal protection (Gill) and a violation of the 10th amendment that delegates broad powers to the states (Commonwealth).

It's a great pair of opinions by Judge Joseph Tauro, appointed to the bench by Richard Nixon. From the Gill decision (and with my emphases):
This court can readily dispose of the notion that denying federal recognition to same-sex marriages might encourage responsible procreation, because the government concedes that this objective bears no rational relationship to the operation of DOMA. Since the enactment of DOMA, a consensus has developed among the medical, psychological, and social welfare communities that children raised by gay and lesbian parents are just as likely to be well-adjusted as those raised by heterosexual parents.But even if Congress believed at the time of DOMA’s passage that children had the best chance at success if raised jointly by their biological mothers and fathers, a desire to encourage heterosexual couples to procreate and rear their own children more responsibly would not provide a rational basis for denying federal recognition to same-sex marriages. Such denial does nothing to promote stability in heterosexual parenting. Rather, it “prevent[s] children of same-sex couples from enjoying the immeasurable advantages that flow from the assurance of a stable family structure,” when afforded equal recognition under federal law.

Moreover, an interest in encouraging responsible procreation plainly cannot provide a rational basis upon which to exclude same-sex marriages from federal recognition because, as Justice Scalia pointed out in his dissent to Lawrence v. Texas, the ability to procreate is not now, nor has it ever been, a precondition to marriage in any state in the country....

I like that dig at Scalia, who was vehemently opposed to the decriminalization of homosexuality in the Lawrence case. This takes out the procreation argument.
But more generally, this court cannot discern a means by which the federal government’s denial of benefits to same-sex spouses might encourage homosexual people to marry members of the opposite sex. And denying marriage-based benefits to same-sex spouses certainly bears no reasonable relation to any interest the government might have in making heterosexual marriages more secure.

What remains, therefore, is the possibility that Congress sought to deny recognition to same-sex marriages in order to make heterosexual marriage appear more valuable or desirable. But to the extent that this was the goal, Congress has achieved it "only by punishing same-sex couples who exercise their rights under state law." And this the Constitution does not permit. 

"For if the constitutional conception of ‘equal protection of the laws’ means anything, it must at the very least mean" that the Constitution will not abide such "a bare congressional desire to harm a politically unpopular group."
That takes out the "defending/protecting straight marriage" Meme. Remember those opposed to marriage equality have never been able to point at any deleterious result in Massachusetts or other states.
Neither does the Constitution allow Congress to sustain DOMA by reference to the objective of defending traditional notions of morality. As the Supreme Court made abundantly clear in Lawrence v. Texas and Romer v. Evans, “the fact that the governing majority in a State has traditionally viewed a particular practice as immoral is not a sufficient reason for upholding a law....”

In other words, take YOUR religion out of MY rights.
....In sum, this court is soundly convinced, based on the foregoing analysis, that the government’s proffered rationales, past and current, are without “footing in the realities of the subject addressed by [DOMA].” And “when the proffered rationales for a law are clearly and manifestly implausible, a reviewing court may infer that animus is the only explicable basis.[Because] animus alone cannot constitute a legitimate government interest,” this court finds that DOMA lacks a rational basis to support it.....Indeed, Congress undertook this classification for the one purpose that lies entirely outside of legislative bounds, to disadvantage a group of which it disapproves. And such a classification, the Constitution clearly will not permit.

. ....And where, as here, “there is no reason to believe that the disadvantaged class is different, in relevant respects” from a similarly situated class, this court may conclude that it is only irrational prejudice that motivates the challenged classification.As irrational prejudice plainly never constitutes a legitimate government interest, this court must hold that Section 3 of DOMA as applied to Plaintiffs violates the equal protection principles embodied in the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
The dislike and fear paraded through the Prop8 trial are dismissed by this Judge of the 1st US DIstrict Court as the bias they are. You don't get to discriminate just because you don't like us.

What next? Well, as with the Perry case, the next step would be appeal to the (1st?) Circuit Court of Appeals, and after that to SCOTUS. The interesting thing here is that the government is defending DOMA: Pres Obama's Justice Department is arguing that while it is discriminatory, it is still constitutional. And Pres Obama is supposed to be a "fierce advocate" for GLBT rights. So the Administration has got a tiger by the ear, here.

If the decisions stand, I'm not sure of the breadth; do they only apply to states and marriages within the geographical confines of the 1st District, or would it apply across the country?

Does this affect the Perry (Proep8) case? That's a much broader case with a more sweeping question: whether or not same sex marriage bans are Constitutional. The DOMA cases didn't address that at all, they simply asked, given same sex marriages, whether it is Constitutional for the Federal Government to discriminate. (The reason Prop8 is not being defended by the government is that neither the Governor nor the Attorney General in CA supported Prop8, and they refused to defend it. Therefore THAT case is being defended explicitly by the promoters of Prop8.) I'm sure that Judge Walker will read these opinions, but I don't know how it might affect his decision.

According to the NY TImes, legal scholars are split on whether this will hold up in appeal, but nearly everyone says it will be appealed. Lots of reactions compiled by Andrew Sullivan worry this could be an expensive victory, if it's overturned.

Friday, June 1, 2012

The DOMA decision: Clause 3 is unconstitutional

Yesterday, there was big news that the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit found DOMA unconstitutional.

The background: DOMA has two relevant clauses. One allows states to refuse to recognize legal same sex marriages performed by other states.  The second prevents recognition of legal same sex marriages by the federal government. Several cases are working through the federal courts that challenge the federal recognition clause (clause 3). The one in Massachusetts is a consolidation of several cases; the state of MA is a plaintiff in one of them because it is being forced to treat its same-sex married citizens differently. This case was first decided by a district court judge in 2010 and now the appeal has been decided by a panel of three judges from the First Circuit  Court of Appeals.

The three judges found unanimously that DOMA violates equal protection statutes. (Two of the judges are conservatives, appointed by Republican presidents.) The decision is narrower than the original district court decision (similar to the narrow decision we saw in the prop8 appeal). And, it has been stayed because the court expects this to go to SCOTUS.

As Chris Geidner writes,
While giving credence to several of the factors -- from sexual orientation discrimination to federalism -- that each independently were considered decisive by U.S. District Court Judge Joseph Tauro, the appellate opinion, written by Judge Michael Boudin, was a far more narrow ruling that decided the case on the sole grounds that Congress gave no rational basis for enacting the law.

The decision also takes down the argument that blocking same sex couples from marrying somehow strengthens straight marriages and promotes procreation.

Whether or not children raised by opposite-sex marriages are on average better served, DOMA cannot preclude same-sex couples in Massachusetts from adopting children or prevent a woman partner from giving birth to a child to be raised by both partners. 
DOMA does not increase benefits to opposite-sex couples--whose marriages may in any event be childless, unstable or both--or explain how denying benefits to same-sex couples will reinforce heterosexual marriage. Certainly, the denial will not affect the gender choices of those seeking marriage. This is not merely a matter of poor fit of remedy to perceived problem, but a lack of any demonstrated connection between DOMA's treatment of same-sex couples and its asserted goal of strengthening the bonds and benefits to society of heterosexual marriage.

Many commentators think this narrow decision is more tailored to an eventual Supreme Court decision overturning DOMA, and making legally married gay couples married in the eyes of the federal government as well.  That will depend on whether the defenders of DOMA (the hired gun Paul Clement, of the misnamed Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group from Congress, since the DoJ won't defend it) appeal to the Supremes and are granted certiorari.

As one of those legally married couples, that would be very welcome.
(I am not a lawyer, though I enjoy thinking about constitutional law issues.  so please, any lawyers let me know if there are corrections required.)

<B>Updated </B> thanks to loyal reader and attorney Paul (A) who corrected some of my language.  

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

A new DOMA case

On Friday, a new DOMA case began: Golinski v OPM. I've told you previously about the ongoing effort of Karen Golinski, an employee of the Ninth Circuit court of appeals, to get medical coverage for her wife. (The Ninth Circuit is hearing the Prop8 appeal.)

Chief Judge Kozinski, who heard Golinski's employee grievance, agreed, because the Ninth does not allow discrimination on the basis of orientation. But the Office of Personnel Management refused to comply because of DOMA. (It's a great irony that OPM is headed by John Berry, the highest ranking gay appointed by President Obama.)

Now, Ms Golinski is suing OPM in US District Court. The Advocate reports,
Part of Lambda's argument against OPM in this case is that DOMA is unconstitutional, specifically because it discriminates based on sex and sexual orientation and it infringes on the right to privacy. Lambda is arguing that the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Lawrence v. Texas, which in 2003 overturned laws against sodomy, set a precedent for the federal government respecting one's familial relationships.

Lambda Legal also plans to tell district court judge Jeffrey White that he need not find DOMA unconstitutional to rule that Golinski's spouse is entitled to health insurance. "OPM, under the authority of President Obama, is part of the Executive Branch of the federal government, and lacks authority to override internal personnel decisions made by the Judicial Branch as it works to end discrimination against lesbian and gay court employees," says a press release from Lambda Legal.
It's worth reminding you that OPM has already been sued twice on DOMA: First in Gill v OPM. In this case, a legally married Massachusetts resident sued for a federal work benefit for her wife. Federal Judge Joseph Tauro found that the clause of DOMA that prevents federal recognition of legal same sex marriages was unconstitutional. Obama's Department of Justice is appealing the ruling. (The appeal is necessary if it is to extend beyond Massachusetts--it has to get into the Circuit courts of appeal and up to the SCOTUS).

The second case, currently pending, is Pederson v OPM, which challenges state and private entities that rely on DOMA to deny benefits to married same sex couples.

Now we can add Golinski v. OPM. As always, I will follow these here..

Picture from the Advocate

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Big news on DOMA

I've been behind in posting here due to work and travel commitments. There is big news in the DOMA front. Recall up to this point that the Dept of Justice is not defending DOMA in court, although it is still enforcing it.

And recall the Golinski case, in which a married California woman (ironically an employee of the 9th circuit federal court) is suing for health benefits for her wife. The government's defense is from attorney Paul Clement, hired by the Republicans in Congress since the DoJ won't defend.

Not only won't the DoJ defend, however, they are actively supporting Golinski AND challenging DOMA, in a newly filed brief. From Chris Geidner:
DOJ lawyers today made an expansive case in a 31-page filing that DOMA is unconstitutional. ... In describing why heightened scrutiny applies to classifications based on sexual orientation, for example, the DOJ's lawyers -- in describing how "gays and lesbians have been subject to a history of discrimination" -- write, "The federal government has played a significant and regrettable role in the history of discrimination against gay and lesbian individuals."...

Today's filing does more than acknowledge the federal government's role in discrimination, going on to detail specific instances of anti-gay and anti-lesbian discrimination, including the 1950 Senate resolution seeking an "investigation" into "homosexuals and other sexual perverts" in government employement and President Dwight Eisenhower's executive order adding "sexual perversion" as a ground for "possible dismissal from government service," in the brief's words. It also details the role of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the U.S. Postal Service in investigations seeking information about government employees suspected of such "perversion."

The brief goes on to describe anti-gay and anti-lesbian state and local discrimination, as well as private discrimination, before discussing other considerations made by courts when deciding what level of scrutiny should be applied to laws classifying groups -- including immutability; political powerlessness; and whether the classification bears any relation to, as the brief puts it, "legitimate policy objectives or ability to perform or contribute to society."

DOJ's lawyers conclude that heightened scrutiny applies and argue how, under that heightened scrutiny, Section 3 of DOMA should be found to be unconstitutional. ...

the brief concludes, "[T]he official legislative record makes plain that DOMA Section 3 was motivated in substantial part by animus toward gay and lesbian individuals and their intimate relationships, and Congress identified no other interest that is materially advanced by Section 3. Section 3 of DOMA is therefore unconstitutional."
The brief is here.

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Debunking conservative talking points on DOMA

Equality Matters gives us a useful resource for the inevitable lies about what Obama's DOMA decision really means. Please visit their page for the details including quotes and citations, but here are some highlights.
The Talking Point: Obama Is Refusing To Enforce The Law...The Facts: Obama And The DoJ Will Continue To Enforce DOMA, Despite Not Defending It In Court. ...

The Talking Point: Refusing To Defend DOMA Is Unconstitutional And Unprecedented...The Facts: Legal Precedent Exists For Refusing To Defend Unconstitutional Laws In Court. ...President George W. Bush Did The Same Thing When He Was President....As did President Bill Clinton....And President George H. W. Bush....Also, President Ronald Reagan...

The Talking Point: Obama Is Flip-Flopping In Order To Appease His Base...The Facts: Obama Has Been In Favor Of Repealing DOMA Since Before He Was Even Elected. ...

The Talking Point: Obama Wants To Force States To Recognize Out-Of-State Same-Sex Marriage...The Facts: Holder Only Dropped The Defense Of Section 3 Of DOMA. The suits currently challenging DOMA in the courts are specific to Section 3 of the law. Section 3 has to do with federal recognition of same-sex marriages already approved by the states....

The Talking Point: Obama Is Ignoring The Will Of The People... The Facts: Americans Are Evenly Divided On Marriage Equality. A poll released by the Associated Press in August of 2010 found that a narrow majority of Americans now supports federal recognition of married same-sex couples. 52% of respondents were in favor of marriage equality, with 46% opposed. ......

The Talking Point: Obama Is Wading Into Social Issues When He Should Be Focusing On The Economy....The Facts: Obama Was Legally Required To Take A Stand On The DOMA Lawsuits By March 11. ...

Friday, April 22, 2011

Congress to defend DOMA with your tax dollars

Okay, so the country is divided pretty equally on marriage equality, with a narrow majority favoring equality. If you throw civil unions into the mix, there is a strong majority in favor of some form of recognition of committed gay couples. The anti-equality folks are slipping further the fringe, equating gays with incest and pedophila.

As we've discussed many times, DOMA prevents the federal government from recognizing legal marriages between same sex partners from Equality States. So, for example, the federal government treats me and my wife as single despite our valid marriage license.

Not surprisingly, there are a number of cases in various circuits of the federal court system challenging this on equal protection grounds (again, we've covered them extensively here at GMC). With the decision of the Obama administration not to defend DOMA, Congress has stepped in. Speaker Boehner has allotted $500,000 to a politically powerful law firm, King and Spalding, to defend these DOMA cases.

Now, while that's a lot of money, in the grander scheme of things, it's not really much at all. The Prop8 trial so far has cost more than $1.5million in attorney fees to Ted Olson's firm. And that's just for ONE case.  Poliglot uncovers evidence that the $500,000 from the government is no cap at all. That is, you the taxpayer may be on the hook for millions and millions of dollars to defend the following multiple cases:

In addition to the Windsor v. United States case in which King & Spalding attorney Paul Clement already has filed a motion on behalf of the BLAG seeking to intervene in the case, two appeals in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit (Gill v. Office of Personnel Management and Massachusetts v. United States), a case at the trial court level in Connecticut (Pedersen v. Office of Personnel Management) and federal court employee Karen Golinski's attempt in a federal court in California to get health benefits for her wife (Golinski v. Office of Personnel Management) are ongoing, there also are six other cases listed by the Department of Justice in a Feb. 25 memorandum sent by Assistant Attorney General Robert Weich to Boehner as being impacted by the DOJ DOMA decision.
And in the final irony, the law firm King and Spalding boasts of its gay-friendly diversity policies.

But wait--there's more.

The government contract to K&S specifically forbids attorneys at the firm from advocating for DOMA repeal, even if they are not involved in the litigation. Yes, apparently, they are trying to muzzle the personal activities of individuals not involved in the case.

Metroweekly tells us that this muzzle may be illegal in some states.
Jon Davidson, the legal director at Lambda Legal, told Metro Weekly that in some states the provision might be illegal. Davidson specifically pointed to California, where King & Spalding has two offices, in which Labor Code Section 1101 states that "[n]o employer shall make, adopt, or enforce any rule, regulation, or policy ... [f]orbidding or preventing employees from engaging or participating in politics ...."

Talking about the statute, which would be applicable in King & Spalding's San Francisco and Silicon Valley offices, Davidson said, "It's not just illegal, it's criminal. It also gives rise to civil liability."
...

Neither of the two partners named on King & Spalding's "LGBT Lawyers" page on its website – Diversity Committee chair Samuel M. Matchett or Sam Griffin – responded to multiple requests seeking comment about the impact of the DOMA representation on LGBT recruitment at the firm.
Disgusting as it is, there is a certain irony to this.

The firm chosen to defend DOMA prides itself on LGBT diversity. I'm sure they are bright and accomplished. So that suggests that LGBT unfriendly firms with the appropriate qualifications maybe aren't so sharp (we saw that in some of the Prop8 case work). The sad thing, though, is that the firm in question is willing to sell its principles for money.

What a perfect Republican firm THAT is.

Saturday, June 13, 2009

DOMA defense worse than we think

While it can be argued that the DoJ has to defend DOMA, which (like it or not) is the law of the land right now, much of the fuss and bother over the DoJ's brief is in its savage depiction of gays and lesbians. It's every awful right-wing talking point. Just imagine what it will cost us in the political struggle to have THESE words thrown back at us as "Obama's DoJ says..."

John Culhane writes it's even worst than we think.
.... once that strategy matter is decided, there are all sorts of briefs one might write. The simplest, and least harmful, would have been to challenge the case on standing (since the plaintiffs hadn’t “applied” for federal benefits); to the extent a more substantive argument were thought advisable, a standard-issue argument about judicial deference would have sufficed. At the other end of the spectrum is the brief that was actually written.....The brief is a jaw-dropping assault on gays and lesbians. Instead of the kind of measured and careful response I was expecting (despite the jeremiads I was reading), I got a brief that seems to have been intended to set the course of judicial progress on gay rights back many years. I wish I were exaggerating.

Another lawyer at Lawdork:
Even if one argues, as I often have, that a government lawyer — from the Department of Justice to state attorneys general — must defend even those laws with which one disagrees*, such a lawyer needn’t overstate his or her case. The government lawyer defending a statute with which she disagrees needn’t add gratuitous demeaning statements into the legal brief she files.

Lawdork notes with some sarcasm in a related post,
It’s good to know that as Obama Department of Justice was putting the finishing touches on its pro-DOMA Motion to Dismiss in Smelt v. United States, it sent its highest-ranked openly gay Administration official to praise the President at an LGBT event at the DOJ....Although he didn’t realize, Berry’s question is best posed to the president or Holder themselves: “Where do you stand? Honoring love as precious and true wherever you find it, or with those who would demean or deny it?” In its DOMA filing, the Justice Department both demeaned LGBT people and denied our love.

Others are also gobsmacked. From The Independent Gay Forum:
It is gratuitously insulting to lesbians and gay men, referring (unnecessarily) to same-sex marriage as a “form” of marriage, approving of congressional comparisons between same-sex marriages and loving relationships between siblings, or grandparents and grandchildren, and arguing (with a straight face, I can only assume) that discrimination against same-sex couples is rational because it saves the federal government money. There are some respectable arguments in this motion, and this kind of disrespect is offensive.

Andrew Sullivan:
The deployment of arguments that refer to our relationships as equivalent to incest, that demand that we simply marry someone of the opposite sex if we want our civil rights, that implies federal recognition of our civil marriages would mean taxing some Americans to pay for something they abhor: this is simply salt in the wound, and it will be deployed and used by every far right gay-hater in the future, and cited as endorsed by the Obama administration.

The mainstream gay groups say (including ACLU, GLAD, Lambda Legal, NCLR, HRC and NGLTF)
When President Obama was courting lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender voters, he said that he believed that DOMA should be repealed. We ask him to live up to his emphatic campaign promises, to stop making false and damaging legal arguments, and immediately to introduce a bill to repeal DOMA and ensure that every married couple in America has the same access to federal protections.

The Justice department scrambled to defend themselves.
As it generally does with existing statute, the Justice Department is defending the law on the books,” said Justice Department spokesperson Tracy Schmaler. “As you know, the president has said he wants to see a legislative repeal of DOMA, but until Congress passes legislation repealing the law, the administration will continue to defend the statute when it’s challenged.

The president, that "fierce advocate"? Sullivan again:
I also understand the need to defend existing law. But the zealous defense of DOMA - including repeating countless spurious and unnecessary slurs against gay people - need not be a lawyer's duty. It is a choice by his political superiors. It is not the fact of this brief, it is its contents and rhetoric that sting. They did not have to go this far.....The more I learn the clearer it is that this was a conscious decision by Obama's DOJ to use evey conceivable argument to kill any constitutional attack on DOMA. At the same time, they are clearly committed to doing nothing in the foreseeable future to enact any redress for those couples currently denied their civil rights. On top of this, they obviously did nothing to prepare gay couples or any gay leaders for this swipe at them. Why? Are relations that broken? Some judicious explanation ahead of time would surely have been in everyone's interest. But again, one gets the impression that for the Obama administration, gay people are a burden, a distraction and a bore.

This brief goes beyond narrow definitions and legal parsing. It's brutalizing. And for an administration that is supposed to be so on the ball, so talented, so on-message, it's hard to believe that no one reviewed this. Knowing how the GLBT community has been feeling, it's absolutely remarkable that a brief straight out of the Bush era got though with these kinds of arguments. So, I see several possibilities. (1) Sullivan is right, and the White House doesn't care. (2) it has made a calculating decision to make the GLBT community the whipping boy, to show the right-wingers in this quest for bi-partisanship that they can all agree on the icky gays, or (3) it is hoping this thing gets refute forcefully in court. But wouldn't possibility (3) be against legal ethics? Lawyers don't write briefs intending to lose. So sadly, regretfully, I can't see much likelihood in (3).

And this vicious hurtful brief was ironically released on June 12, the 42nd anniversary of Loving v. Virginia.

Update From Joe Sudbay
Yesterday, a Democratic President of the United States of America, in the year 2009, and an African-American child of inter-racial parents no less, gave his lawyers the go ahead to compare our marriages to incest on the same day that 42 years ago the Supreme Court ruled in his parents' favor in Loving v. Virginia. And these people, along with our President, are suggesting that the appropriate response is to shrug our shoulders and go home, since, after all, the law is the law?


Update from gay activist David Mixner:
You fully need to understand the ramifications of this brief: it undercuts every conceivable argument that the LGBT community would use to fight for the repeal of DOMA. Right-wing nut cases can now just simply quote horrible stuff from this hateful brief and proclaim loudly it was filed by the Obama Justice Department. The President and his team have not only undercut this community but have damaged his own ability to repeal this hideous law given to us by President Clinton. With Democratic friends like these, God helps us.

Friday, December 16, 2011

Hearing today on DOMA

Today, there will be oral arguments on one of the many DOMA cases working their way through the federal courts: the Golinski case, in which a legally married California woman, Karen Golinski, was denied health coverage for her spouse. (The kicker here is that she works for the federal courts). Frankly, I would much rather see this go to the Supremes than Prop8, right now--I don't trust the Supremes on Prop8, but the DOMA clause 3  issue is a slam dunk failure of equal protection big enough for Antonin Scalia to see.  Legally married couples are treated differently by the federal government for no reason but their gender.

This case is a big deal,because the Department of Justice will actually be arguing against DOMA, which will be defended by the expensive lawyer bought by the Republicans in Congress (called BLAG). From The Advocate:
Tony West, assistant attorney general of the Justice Department’s civil division, told The Advocate that his Friday arguments in federal district court will center on why Section 3 of DOMA, which bars federal recognition of same-sex marriages, should be subject to heightened judicial scrutiny — in part given the long history of discrimination against gays and lesbians in the United States.

“This issue is really about whether the federal government, in distributing health insurance benefits, can pick and choose on the basis of sexual orientation when deciding whom to confer benefits,” West said. “Here is a married couple who, for all intents and purposes, is the same as anyone else, with one distinguishing characteristic, and that is sexual orientation.”
The Advocate also tells us about some of the specific questions the judge hearing the case has put forth for the attorneys:
Earlier this week, U.S. district judge Jeffrey S. White issued a two-page list of questions to attorneys on DOMA’s constitutionality and whether the law should be subjected to heightened scrutiny. Among them to be addressed Friday in court: 
  • How does treating some state sanctioned marriages different from others promote consistency or maintain the status quo? 
  • How does the withholding of federal benefits to children of families with same-sex parents encourage responsible parenting and child-rearing?
  • Is the [Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group] actually bipartisan? Does BLAG have the support – and funding for the increasing cost of defending DOMA – from a majority of Congress or just from the House of Representatives?
  • How does BLAG distinguish the line of authority treating classifications based on religious affiliation as a suspect class from classifications based on sexual orientation?

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

Over 70 companies file brief opposing DOMA

The Advocate tells us that 70 companies and organizations, including Google, Microsoft,and Starbucks, have filed an amicus brief in one of the DOMA cases now winding through federal court. The companies complain that DOMA hurts their recruiting, and causes unnecessary administrative burdens. Good to see!
Their brief points out that the Republican leadership in the House of Representatives is defending DOMA in court on the notion that it imposes "a uniform rule" on whose marriage is recognized. "The perspective of the American employer who must implement DOMA is very different," the companies state. "Employers are obliged to treat one employee spouse differently from another, when each is married, and each marriage is equally lawful."

The companies say DOMA "forces" them "to investigate the gender of the spouses of our lawfully married employees and then to single out those employees with a same-sex spouse." For example, HIPPA laws usually consider marriage a "qualifying event" that automatically enrolls a spouse in an employee's health insurance. Companies now spend time and money weeding out any gay employees who get married.

If companies don't want to discriminate, because it hurts their recruiting efforts or they're just opposed to it in principle, then DOMA causes a bunch of "workarounds" that come with wasteful administrative costs of their own.

Companies complain that when a same-sex couple legally marries, it requires them "to maintain two sets of books." That's because the couple is considered married under state law but not married under federal law. "The double entries ripple through human resources, payroll, and benefits administration," they write.

Friday, July 8, 2011

Equality update/FAQ

In the wake of New York's landmark decision, and based on conversations around the blogs, I thought I would give you an update on marriage equality battles.

Will married gay couples from NY be recognized elsewhere?
  • No state will be required to recognize marriages performed in New York. Like my marriage in CA, or same sex marriages from MA, the marriages in NY will be legally invisible in over 30 states. This is thanks to section 2 of DOMA (the defense of marriage act) which states explicitly that no state has to recognize a gay couple.

But I thought that DOMA was overturned by the Department of Justice
  • No. The DoJ is not defending DOMA in court, but it remains the law of the land and is still enforced. There are at least 6 DOMA cases pending in different circuits of the federal courts. These have all challenged section 3, which forbids the federal government from recognizing legally married gay couples, like me. DOMA was already found unconstitutional in the 1st circuit, but that's being appealed. Unless and until it gets to the Supreme Court (SCOTUS), however, individual decisions will only affect the states within that federal court circuit. 

  • There is a bill that would repeal DOMA being put forward in Congress ("Respect for Marriage Act"), which led to a moving hearing on July 20. Despite that, it is unlikely to go very far because of Republican opposition.

How does this relate to the Prop8 case?
  • The Prop8 case addresses the right to marry, NOT whether it will be recognized (as in the DOMA cases). Briefly: In California in 2008, the State Supreme Court found for marriage equality (and overturned Prop22, which had made a law forbidding it). However, 8 months later, Prop8 was approved by the voters, this time amending the state Constitution to forbid equal marriage. The State Court agreed that the voters had that right under the state Constitution, but determined that aside from the name "marriage," gay couples should have all the rights of marriage. It also determined that the 18,000 couples married in the "summer of love" were still legally married.

  • A case was then brought in federal court arguing that Prop8 violated the US Constitution. Judge Vaughn Walker agreed. That case was appealed to the 9th circuit, where there are two issues to determine. The first issue is whether or not the appellants (the supporters of Prop8) have standing to appeal. Confusingly, this turns on an issue of state law regarding propositions, so the 9th circuit has asked the State Supreme Court to advise them. (The state court will hear the argument in the fall). The second issue, assuming they have standing, is whether the decision was sound. Ultimately, either or both of these issues will be appealed all the way to the US Supreme Court (SCOTUS).

  • Meanwhile, in a side-show typical of the whole case, the Prop8 supporters filed a different argument against Republican-appointed Judge Vaughn Walker, who in a delicious bit of irony, is gay. Their claim that this rendered him unable to judge impartially was dismissed by the court. Naturally, they are going to  appeal.

Is New York the first legislature to support marriage equality?
  • No. New Hampshire, Vermont, Connecticut, Maine, and California legislatures all passed equality. In Maine, it was overturned by voter referendum, and in California, then-Gov Schwarzeneggar declined to sign it.

What about the voters?
  • If you had asked the electorate in Alabama in 1960 whether they supported civil rights, probably the schools would have remained segregated. Sadly, in no case where equality has been left to the voters, have they passed it. Upcoming  elections in 2012 will include Minnesota and North Carolina, and possibly Maine where they will try to repeal the referendum that overturned equality. Right now it looks unlikely that we will go to the ballot in CA next year.

Friday, December 7, 2012

BREAKING: SCOTUS will hear both Prop8 and DOMA cases

Today the court granted cert to the Prop8 case, and to one of the DOMA cases (Windsor). Included in their questions is a request for arguments about whether the defenders of the status quo have standing to argue the cases.

I do not like this.  The cleanest result for us would be to deny cert for Prop8 and restore marriage equality to CA.  If they find against us, it is broadly possible they could find NO right to marriage in the US,  and that would be as bad as Bowers v. Hardwick.

The waiting, for those of us fighting Prop8, now continues.

From the Live blog at Scotusblog:
Prop. 8 is granted on the petition question -- whether 14th Am. bars Calif. from defining marriage in traditional way. Plus an added question: Whether the backers of Prop.. 8 have standing in the case under Art. III.  

In Windsor, the government petition (12-307) is the one granted. In addition to the petition question -- whether Sec. 3 of DOMA violates equal protection under 5th Amendment, there are two other questions: does the fact that government agreed with the 2d CA decision deprive the Court of jurisdiction to hear and decide the case, and whether BLAG (House GOP leaders) has Art. III standing in this case.  

Trying to sort this all out, it is clear that the Court has agreed to consider the merits case in Prop. 8, because that is what the petition presented as its question, but that it is also going to address whether the proponents had a right to pursue their case. If the Court were to find that the proponents did not have Art. III standing, that is the end of the matter: there would be no review on the merits of Proposition 8, or of the 9th CA decision striking it down. 

Trying to sort out DOMA: The case has agreed to consider the merits issue of the constitutionality of DOMA Section 3, it has also given itself the option of not deciding that issue. If it finds that neither the Executive Branch could bring its appeal, and that BLAG lacked Art. III standing, then presumably both of those petitions would be denied. At that point, then, the Court might have to consider whether it wants to hear another DOMA case. But that probably would not be done in time for this term's close. 
There is a good deal of complexity in the marriage orders, but the bottom line is this: the Court has offered to rule on Prop. 8 and on DOMA Section 3, but it also has given itself a way not to decide either case. That probably depends upon how eager the Justices are to get to the merits; if they are having trouble getting to 5 on the merits, they may just opt out through one of the procedural devices they have offered up as potentials.   
Olson and Boies are on the other side of the Prop. 8 case. I assume their brief and oral argument will go heavily against standing for the Prop. 8 backers, but also will urge the SCt to affirm the 9th CA on the merits. Since the 9th CA decision is very different from Judge Walker's decision, I doubt that they will be asking the Court to rule as Judge Walker did. 
The key point, though, is that if they succeed in challenging the backers on the standing issue, the case is over: Prop. 8 is gone under the 9th CA decision, because there is no one to defend it. If there is no standing in Prop. 8, presumably that might lead to a ruling that the 9th CA decision has to be vacated. But then Judge Walker's decision would be the law of the case, because that was fully litigated with parties who clearly had standing. Prop. 8 backers would lose in an even bigger way.

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

The problem with the DOMA repeal

Andrew Sullivan recently highlighted a survey from the HRC about the harmful effects of DOMA on the GLBT community.

Okay, we all agree that DOMA needs to go. And, refreshingly, there is a bill from Rep Gerry Nadler with 91 cosponsors that would repeal this craven piece of bigotry. There was a press conference Tuesday about it.

But there are several pieces to DOMA, and it is politically much more expedient (and more likely to succeed) if it is eliminated in parts. Because nothing fires up the right wing base of H8 like think that gay marriage is coming to their state.

So, start by eliminating the federal rejection, and then work on the state by state basis to get it passed in individual states. (As we've seen they are in very different places on this topic-- you might want to revisit my stats post on the subject.)

LawDork reports that no less a politician than Barney Frank thinks this is not a good way to go about it. Frank thinks that it endangers other, more achieveable goals, and has problems as written. Much as I long for the death of DOMA, I recognize that it will take some time. Barney's a consummate pol, as well as an out gay man. I'd like to chip away at this thing and start its downfall, rather than tilt at it like a windmill and get absolutely nothing. But don't we have to start hammering?

LawDork explains (in a previous post)
Following clarification from Rep. Nadler’s office, the “certainty provision” would not require a state where same-sex marriages are prohibited to itself recognize a marriage validly entered into by a same-sex couple elsewhere. It would, however, mean that if a same-sex couple married in Iowa moved to, say, Ohio, then the couple’s marriage would still be recognized as valid for federal legal purposes.

Even in that situation, though, a state where same-sex marriages are prohibited by statute or the state’s constitution would, with the bill’s passage, be in the position of having residents that it considers to be unmarried living in the state recognized as married by the federal government. Although not as extreme as compelling the state itself to recognize the same-sex marriage, this seems to me to still cause significant opposition from not only marriage equality opponents but also some who are more agnostic on the issue but want to see the issue “left to the states” to come to their own decision.
I'm really torn. I can see why this is a problem, but the huge, huge issue with DOMA is that legally married citizens are NOT given federal rights. The certainty provision guarantees that. Otherwise, a legal marriage evaporates FEDERALLY if you leave the jurisdiction. I not sure how to get around this, though I agree that the last thing we need to do is start the entire Evangelical movement attacking us again. If you're going to poke a dragon, you'd better have a plan for escaping the flames. Is Frank being too cautious? Is Nadler being too ambitious?

Andrew Sullivan comments,
"The provision that says you can take your benefits as you travel, I think, will stir up unnecessary opposition with regard to the question of are you trying to export it to other states," [Frank] said. "If we had a chance to pass that, it would be a different story, but I don't think it's a good idea to rekindle that debate when there's no chance of passage in the near term."

Nadler defended the legislation in a statement, saying that claims made by repeal opponents shouldn't prevent the bill's introduction.....

Nadler emphasized that the proposed bill wouldn't force any state to marry gay couples or recognize same-sex couples under state law.

It's a real kick in the teeth - and HRC hasn't responded. To have the leading gay congressman say that gay couples can wait helps put into perspective Obama's caution.
There's an old saying: don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. I get that. But surely, SURELY, the good demands more than nothing?

Update here's from Rep Nadler's press release:
The Respect for Marriage Act ... would ensure that valid marriages are respected under federal law, providing couples with much-needed certainty that their lawful marriages will be honored under federal law and that they will have the same access to federal responsibilities and rights as all other married couples.

The Respect of Marriage Act would accomplish this by repealing DOMA in its entirety and by adopting the place-of-celebration rule recommended in the Uniform Marriage and Divorce Act, which embraces the common law principle that marriages that are valid in the state where they were entered into will be recognized. While this rule governs recognition of marriage for purposes of federal law, marriage recognition under state law would continue to be decided by each state.

The Respect for Marriage Act would not tell any state who can marry or how married couples must be treated for purposes of state law, and would not obligate any person, church, city or state to celebrate or license a marriage of two people of the same sex. It would merely restore the approach historically taken by states of determining, under principles of comity and Full Faith and Credit, whether to honor a couple’s marriage for purposes of state law.
Phone your Congresscritters and urge support: the NOMmers are having a meltdown over this.